HTC hits back. Again. Filling a new lawsuit against Apple using patents bought from Google

8 September 2011 by
News Articles:

Technical details:

From the forum:
Another lawsuit this week. HTC is suing Apple using 9 new patents bought from Google last week.

HTC vs Apple lawsuit 

It's not easy to keep track of who's suing who in the mobile industry these days. Several infographics has been created to see which company are the target of the latest lawsuits. We are not even trying to keep track on these lines or make a chart our self. But Reuters has made one of those infographics and they call it the graphic of the day. Things are happening so fast these days that the lines must be updated weekly to be correct.

HTC bought 9 patents from Google last week and they are using these to file a complaint against Apple at the International Trad Commission in the U.S. Mac, iPhone, iPod, iPad, iCloud and iTunes are services HTC claims are infringing their patents for a way to upgrade software wirelessly. Another patent infringed is a method to store user preferences.

If this war of patents are escalating further, the remaining mobile phone manufactures will in 10 years from now not be the companies making the best products, but the company with with the largest patent portfolio.

It is not going to be easy for new companies to enter the mobile phone business. From every piece of hardware inside a modern mobile phone to the size of the navigation icons are patented. A new company not having a patent portfolio will have to pay for the usage of each patents.


Alternatively post this in the Esato forum

Please sign in to your Esato account to leave a comment regarding this article

Member name

Dups!6 years, 9 months ago
This is so tiring! It has become so out of hand thanks to a large part to Apple.
When I think back then there weren't so many lawsuits and they never really became so intense.
julias6 years, 9 months ago
Nice one HTC hope they win and bring Apple crashing down its time someone made Apple wake up and realise that they don't own the Technology market and since Google now owns most of the Patents to Motorola they should joint sue Apple along with Samsung and HTC.
I'm really losing respect for Apple fast!
Bonovox6 years, 9 months ago
These lawsuits must be costing Apple a fortune. It is tiring and the thing that got me recently was the story of Apple blocking sales of Samsung Galaxy Tab in Australia. What gives them the right to do this?? And they say they need to prove to the courts that the sales of the Samsung Tab affected their sales. Duh,hello Apple it's called COMPETETION!!
admad6 years, 9 months ago
Well that's the price for being a patent troll (patenting ideas like scrolling through pictures and then suing other companies) serves them right. Hope they will loose this
bangsters6 years, 9 months ago
I'm getting fed up with these lawsuits. apple started this whole debacle, and I hope they come crashing back to earth.
I used to want an iphone4. good thing i went HTC instead. Now my macbooks might be finding their way to ebay......
good one HTC!!
[ This Message was edited by: bangsters on 2011-09-09 15:42 ]
Miss UK6 years, 9 months ago
Nice one well spoken @ Bangster
and Good on HtC I hope they make a Apple crumble out of them for all these shenanighans!
masseur6 years, 7 months ago
US agency says Apple did not violate HTC patents (BBC article)
A US agency has ruled that Apple did not violate graphic patents owned by S3 Graphics, a unit of Taiwan's HTC.
S3, which makes image compression technology, filed a complaint with trade agency, ITC, in May 2010.
The company accused Apple of infringing four patents, which it said were used widely in a range of Apple products.
anonymuser6 years, 7 months ago
I love this thread, it's hilarious!
Original post:
HTC have bought some patents from Google specifically for the purposes of suing Apple for infringement.
Everyone else's response:
Damn Apple for these lawsuits! They're patent trolls! They'll do everyone out of business! Why don't Apple just innovate! Etc etc ad infinitum..
[ This Message was edited by: Boinng on 2011-11-22 13:22 ]
masseur6 years, 7 months ago
lol, I'd long since forgotten about this thread until this news appeared today and I was looking for somewhere to post it
Hobbs6 years, 7 months ago
Business is business.
I can't be bothered who the hell sues who,
as long as every 2 years there is a killer phone available for me to upgrade to from any one of the phone manufacturers.

Miss UK6 years, 7 months ago
it's a Dog Eat World
I own Manufacturers devices as above
all this is becoming pretty boring news we all should let them get on with Killing one another
in court!
Battle Pow Wow HTC VS APPLE

Back to news headlines