Welcome to Esato.com




Dedicated Camera Button, Why None?


Click to view updated thread with images




Posted by skblakee
Why is there no longer a dedicated camera button on most phones? The Galaxy Note 2 for instance is a large phone/small tablet which could very well do with a button for the camera. I find it much easier for taking pictures with the button than having to touch the on screen button.




Posted by Bonovox
Phones becoming too thin?? That's another thing I love about Windows phones,Microsoft always demand to put in a camera key. But besides that maybe it's just touch screen generation,everything is now done by touch screen bar a few side buttons. And phones become so skinny. But saying that the Arc had a camera key albeit a stiff one. I am sure it does not cost much more to make a camera key

Posted by Bonovox
I do find I shake a bit more without a camera key and it's harder to take mug shots of yourself too

Posted by skblakee
I find I also shake more without the camera key as well that is my main reason for wanting it back on the phone. As for being thin there is a power button on them so if they are wide enough for a power button I see no difficulty in putting a dedicated camera button back on the phones.

Oh as for those mugshots, oh yes, another difficulty. Try turning the screen away from you while also trying to touch the onscreen camera button to take a good "mugshot." Not the easiest thing to do at all.

They should put the button back on.

Posted by Bonovox
Yes,if you want a decent mugshot of yourself a front facing camera is crap quality normally. I remember I took a photo of myself(am bit vain) with the first Galaxy S phone. I kept getting my finger in the way and could not find the capture button on screen

Posted by skblakee
I guess they didnt think any of us would want to do mugshots eh?

Posted by rikken
I actually find it easier using the on-screen button. I touch to focus and do not release my thumb until I want to take the picture and like that I find it easier to keep the camera still

Selfportraits are well executed with my Note 2's great front facing camera

Posted by hihihans
I also prefer the screen over a button. I love touchfocus.

Posted by skblakee
I am touch focused as well but taking shots with the screen turned away from you is not as easy as with the button.

Posted by Bonovox
It depends on what you're taking. I find if the camera is very speedy then touch screen is fine. Still prefer a button like a proper camera

Posted by etaab
I also prefer to use a hardware key rather than onscreen button. The Nokia N8 for example has the option to use both.
But i use the actual button.

Btw, if you want to take a self portrait i find rather than using a lower resolution front facing camera i just stick the main camera on self timer. Five seconds usually does it for me. Seems obvious to use this function for such a purpose.


Posted by hihihans
Windows Phone 8 has a camera button as a requirement for the OS.
The full list reads as below:
Qualcomm Snapdragon S4 dual-core processor
Minimum 512MB RAM for WVGA phones; minimum 1GB RAM for 720p / WXGA
Minimum 4GB flash memory
GPS and A-GNSS; GLONASS is supported if OEMs decide to include it
Support for micro-USB 2.0
3.5mm stereo headphone jack with three-button detection support
Rear-facing AF camera with LED or Xenon flash, optional front-facing camera (both need to be VGA or better) and dedicated camera button
Accelerometer, proximity and ambient light sensors, as well as vibration motor (magnetometer and gyroscope are optional)
802.11b/g and Bluetooth (802.11n is optional)
DirectX graphics hardware support with hardware acceleration for Direct3D using programmable GPU
Multi-touch capacitive touch screen with minimum of four simultaneous points



Click to view updated thread with images


© Esato.com - From the Esato mobile phone discussion forum