Posted by paul101
ive took some photographs and want YOU to decide... real or model? (btw i know the answer)
photo 1
photo 2
photo 3
so which photos are real trains and which are models?
_________________
www.paul101.tk
well there's your problem!
[ This Message was edited by: paul101 on 2007-11-30 16:26 ]
Posted by Danny_BFC
1's a toy
2+3 are real
Posted by paul101
oooh and i will be giving out the answer(s) on Thursday (or whenever i can be bothered
) 
/EDIT
ooh and those of you that have me on msn don't even bother pestering me for the answer
(you wont get it)
_________________
www.paul101.tk
well there's your problem!
getting p1i tomorrow
[ This Message was edited by: paul101 on 2007-11-27 17:57 ]
Posted by arien617
Model
Real
Model
Posted by Danny_BFC
infact they all models
Posted by OffLineR
On 2007-11-27 18:51:16, arien617 wrote:
Model
Real
Model
+1
Posted by se_p800
First 2 are models and you tried to trick us on the last one by photoshopping in a fake background, but the train is infact real.
Posted by jcwhite_uk
Model
Model
Real
Posted by Cycovision
All of them are models.
Posted by Sammy_boy
All models, but very realistic looking ones and very realistic looking settings!
Posted by Adz21
all models, ill be very shocked if one isn't!
Posted by Topscooby
On 2007-11-27 19:25:36, Cycovision wrote:
All of them are models.
What he said
Posted by KCC4
Um yeah...
Model Real Model
But the best quiz of all time has to be My Leg or Arm One
im sure you would all agree, nice try Paul 101
Posted by fatreg
Gauge 00 models all of 'em...
Posted by DickySnapples
All models
Posted by goldenface
On 2007-11-27 21:40:28, fatreg wrote:
Gauge 00 models all of 'em...
Not the best 00 models I've seen. Possibly N. Some weathering wouldn't have gone amiss.
Edit: Actually, I'd say probably 00.
[ This Message was edited by: goldenface on 2007-11-27 20:53 ]
Posted by fatreg
mm not sure Goldenface..
I'll stick with 00
either way, all 3 are models!
Posted by paul101
so we have people mostly leaning towards model?
is anyone disagreeing?
_________________
www.paul101.tk
well there's your problem!
getting p1i tomorrow
[ This Message was edited by: paul101 on 2007-11-27 22:19 ]
Posted by leeboy13
a midnight ALL REAL
Posted by J273
I think there all real...using the HD photo editing thingy
Where i think u take 3 photos at different exposurs and blend them together?
Sorry may be wrong.
Posted by msmmsm
All models.
Posted by paul101
hmmm everyone seems to have a different opinion
some people i'd like to see having a guess: masseur jojo tranced and a few others
Posted by OffLineR
so we have to wait them
Posted by paul101
is there anyone unsure??
Posted by leeboy13
im pretty sure theyre real
Posted by OffLineR
I'm sure that I said Model, Real, Model
Posted by paul101
i'll be giving out the answers tomorrow. i can say at least one of yous are right
Posted by A L 3 X
I agree with:
Model, Real, Model
Posted by paul101
any more people taking a guess?
i'll be giving out the answers at about 8pm
Posted by mosdelln
1 - Model
2 - Real
3 - Real
Posted by gola
On 2007-11-27 19:19:20, jcwhite_uk wrote:
Model
Model
Real
Posted by gola
On 2007-11-28 20:22:10, paul101 wrote:
i'll be giving out the answers tomorrow. i can say at least one of yous are right
Posted by KingBooker5
all are models
Posted by Muhammad-Oli
On 2007-11-27 20:34:48, Topscooby wrote:
On 2007-11-27 19:25:36, Cycovision wrote:
All of them are models.
What he said
What them guys's said.
Posted by paul101
i can tell you guys that they are all REAL!!
(photoshopped to create the look that you are looking at a model using mask and lens blur tools)
i gave Some selective blurring of the image(s) to give the impression that you are looking at a model
Posted by Danny_BFC
post the originals then
Posted by paul101
On 2007-11-30 17:48:29, ..:/Ğanny:.. wrote:
post the originals then
i'll see if i can find them, they're on a memory card somewhere, actually done this with photoshop about a month ago
Posted by J273
On 2007-11-28 01:14:46, J273 wrote:
I think there all real...using the HD photo editing thingy
Where i think u take 3 photos at different exposurs and blend them together?
Sorry may be wrong.
I was nearly right.
Posted by *Jojo*
Really
. . . They are ALL trains 
I thuoght the FIRST image was that of - Optimus Prime
Posted by max_wedge
Too many fine details and smoke stains.
But the biggests give away was the fact that all the background was out of focus, yet the subject was ALL in focus. This indicates a narrow apperture, and if the photo was untouched it would be impossible to have all the background and foreground out of focus yet the subject cutting through the background and foreground be ALL in focus. Just not possible so it shows the images have been moddified. So I concluded they had been moddified to hide the folliage which would be real looking as it is much harder to model foliage accurately than the trains themselves.
Also the uneven foreground in the last picture, and the unblurred greenery in the first two, also give it away as real.
Posted by razec
Here's what i've observed:
The train looks real, but the rendring is unrealistic, the two trains were not aligned in the rail imho(how is that?). and the one with a tank looks fake or i should say it's a real train but the photoshop or any editing tool have cloned the tanks to increase it's length.
1: what's that? i believe it's not the a of the train - making some supportive facts that this is a real train(maybe) but it's not in it's real location instead it was cut and pasted to the backgorund we can see
2: again raises doubts if this belongs to the train(front portion) since it looks small and not aligned to the train, also it is too narrow. seems like it's the rear of a train he captured on somewhere
^^ terrible fake of the real train(which was the rear portion you can see here) imho. it seems that he used cloning tool to duplicate the tanks after the blue one see the arrow pointer
the leftmost view of the train proves it's photoshopped and faked (download the picture and zoom in to that point, you'll know what i mean )
^^ here you can see that he cloned and doubled the front part of the train, just added some lines on the ladder to make it different, again just like the previous, it is misaligned to the rail and that means it is not the right place where this train was located the blue cargo loader are cloned too
all in all, they're(trains) all real but faked by cloning and pasting them to a different place
Posted by max_wedge
With all respect, but I don't agree.
In the first pic the engines can't be cloned as they are facing back to back (look closely), and in the third pic they are different sizes (from the second one being further away than the first one) and the two blue carriages are different if you look closely, not cloned at all.
I believe the only mod that was made was to blurr out the background and foreground flora and buildings.
_________________
File System Tweaks for the K750 K750 Tricks
K800 Tips and Themes
Max's K800 Page
[ This Message was edited by: max_wedge on 2007-12-02 10:29 ]
Posted by Muhammad-Oli
Really? I just looked at all the backgrounds which all lack fine details or look far too much like they're modelled. Thats how I got it right
The one with the tree background is most obvious. They look very fake.
Posted by max_wedge
then you are wrong, because according to Paul101 they are all real trains and none of them are models
Posted by Muhammad-Oli
Hahahahaha, thats what I get for staying up til 3am on here. I lose my freaking mind!
Sorry guys... I got it completely wrong and for some reason thought I had it completely right! Retard...
Must admit, it was a neat trick, the backgrounds look very fake.
Posted by leeboy13
i knew it........ seriosuly that was not too hard...... way too much detail on the trains and the fact the backgrounds were blurred it was a give away
Posted by max_wedge
On 2007-12-03 11:06:30, Muhummad-Oli wrote:
Hahahahaha, thats what I get for staying up til 3am on here. I lose my freaking mind!
Sorry guys... I got it completely wrong and for some reason thought I had it completely right! Retard...
Must admit, it was a neat trick, the backgrounds look very fake.
staying up to 3am can do that...
