Welcome to Esato.com




Future slim battle:n76 vs w880 vs razr maxx


Click to view updated thread with images




Posted by Nicksefan
O.K.these are the razr-killers from se and nokia and the other is the heir of razr.they are really slim w880 9.4mm, n76 13.4mm and razr maxx 15mm thick.they have qvga screens,2mp cameras,3g,advanced music players,bluetooth etc.the only differences are form-factor and software-UI
Note! (W880 MAY SUPPORT HSPDA,HAVE BETTER CAM,AND SOME GB MEMORY,IT IS STILL UNCLEAR)
so CHOOSE YOUR FAVORITE!!(don't forget to say why)


Posted by BobaFett
imo its no need for hsdpa in w880, its worth to have it in a symbian fone, not in a walkman one

Posted by goldenface
I agree, HSDPA is for downloading huge files like Word and Excel and PDF files etc.

3G is fast enough for music downloads IMO.

However, we need to see some pics of the above handsets so we can judge the design.

Posted by SaLiH
Here are the pictures.


Sony Ericsson W800i


NOKIA N76


Motorola RAZR maxx

I think I wold go for W800, or maybe Nokia, but no way Motorola!

_________________
My phone history: Nokia 3310->Nokia 2100->Nokia 3100->Sony Ericsson K700i->Sony Ericsson K750i

[ This Message was edited by: SaLiH on 2007-01-09 09:22 ]

Posted by goldenface
On design alone I honestly believe the W880i is the best looking - the Nokia looks like a Frankenstein Monstered version of the V3 and the Moto just doesn't look cool to me.

All my personal opinion of course.

Posted by shaliron
Well actually the W880 is stuck on 2MP. There's no more room for a larger sensor...

But the maxx and N76 are long and wide, but they do have more features to be honest. Not to mention the price differences between them is much greater.

Personally the W880 is not a RAZR killer. It's more a X820, SLVR or 6300 killer.

Posted by nneo
if its on the look's of the phone then its the MOTO RAZR MAXX

if its on the functions and UI its defenatly NOKIA N76 (theres no doubt since it is the latest sambyan and its a N series so its a multimedia computer that have all the possibilities through downloading huge content for its OS)

if we'r looking at the slimness then its the SE W880 cuz thats a fact

over all the best one here is the one that is standing on the middle ground in slimness and on the top ground of functionalities it is the N76 with no rival!!

Posted by Vein
Maxx looks very nice indeed.

Posted by kulorex
I think w880 looks cool

Posted by dancingfate
W880 is the best amongst those three.
RAZR Maxx : Too RAZR, nothing special in design, a bit boring.
Nokia N76 : A bit boring too, RAZR inspired? Too bad for Nokia.

Posted by JaayDon
I think W880 aswell

Only for the fact that I dont like moto and The Nokia doesnt look too appealing

Posted by dandyqb
among the 3? candy bar FTW!




Posted by Rica_bg
And i thought Nokia couldn't get any horrible design... I alweys felt that that "bulge" ( where is the microphone) under the keyboard of the RAZR were ugly - ruining it's disign, but when i saw the N76...ARGH! Nokia really loves squares!!!

It's obvious that the W880 is the best!

Posted by xan K
on the looks alone, the w880 is the best. the moto one is way to boring and that model is over-abused now and the nokia one looks like a giant robot v3 version.

Posted by Tsepz_GP
To be realy honest i would go with the Nokia,im realy just againts SE doing ultra slim phones,im realy against that,i was shocked to see that SE had lowered their standards to such IMO a stupid fad,the thinnest SE shud go is as thin as the W950 and M600,but thats in my opinion, N76 for me

Posted by Stef
For a Nokia Clamshel, the N76 is very attractive, although it is ugly as hell!
For a Motorola Clamshel, the RAZR Maxx is quite specced.. but also ugly!
For a thin SE monoblock/ candybar the Ai isnt that attractive, but well specced though! *Specced = good specifications! *

Posted by voda_jon
the nokia isnt copying ne1... lol.

For a phone to be a certain thickness the keys are gonna have to be wafer thin... or extremely small etc...

So the razr comes out with good small wafer keypad and other manufacturers make their own versions of the keypad and now everyone calls their phone copies because of the little keypad?

N76 an all razrs r very very far apart in terms of everything!!!

Symbian rules and with nokia due to announce more and more of them in all sorts of sizes and shapes... the worlds gonna go symbian mad! TRUST ME!

Posted by BobaFett
I am getting really bored with that razr style and thin madness. Just as voda jon said, i do hope that more and more devices will be symbian based one, cos there is no limit in those at usage

This message was posted from a 6233

Posted by driftmania
Quote:

On 2007-01-10 17:28:33, Stef wrote:
For a Nokia Clamshel, the N76 is very attractive, although it is ugly as hell!
For a Motorola Clamshel, the RAZR Maxx is quite specced.. but also ugly!
For a thin SE monoblock/ candybar the Ai isnt that attractive, but well specced though! *Specced = good specifications! *




are you kidding me? I'm pretty sure that the Ai is the WORST "specced" phone out of the three, it's just thinner then the three. The 2 mp camera is a joke and so is the design. It just looks good because of how SE took the photo. the RAZR MAXX and N76 are the best specced, though are ugly. In fact, all three are ugly.

Posted by Stef
Well, for 9.3 mm the Ai has very good specs. For 13.7 mm the N76 has very very good specs, and well Motorola.. nevermind that one!
Remember that Ai is 9.3 mm and that`s small.
And we haven`t the official specs, or do you know something we don`t know..?

Posted by Dups!
Quote:

On 2007-01-09 10:41:28, goldenface wrote:
On design alone I honestly believe the W880i is the best looking - the Nokia looks like a Frankenstein Monstered version of the V3 and the Moto just doesn't look cool to me.

All my personal opinion of course.



Stole the words right out of my mouth there goldenface. The nokia is downright ugly, there's no other way of looking at it for me.

Posted by shaliron
But the Ai also has the most normal proportions out of the three phones. It's actually got a 46mm width and a 102mm height.

Even when the two others are closed, they are still bigger. But those three phones are in different leagues to each other. There's no point comparing.

Posted by Red_Rach
that nokia phone is gorgeous. Esp the red one!

Posted by Stef
Well said Shaliron! You can`t compare a clam with a candybar neither you can compare and Motorola/ Nokia

Posted by driftmania
Quote:

On 2007-01-13 08:45:01, Stef wrote:
Well, for 9.3 mm the Ai has very good specs. For 13.7 mm the N76 has very very good specs, and well Motorola.. nevermind that one!
Remember that Ai is 9.3 mm and that`s small.
And we haven`t the official specs, or do you know something we don`t know..?




What's wrong with the RAZR MAXX? It has very good specs, better than the Ai, it's just that it's butt ugly and somewhat thick. The Motorola and Nokia aren't in the same class as the Ai. The Morotola and Nokia's phones is the high-ranged while the Ai is more of a mid-range which is most likely gonna cost way more than a mid-end like always.

Posted by Yessir
What about all of the samsungs they are breaking the records with like worlds slimmest slider phones ITS CRAZY!


Posted by lhaizza
I love my MAXX hehehe. SE really looks cool so im going to get one. N76 features are great but the body chrome is peeling and not pure steel as nokia have said.

Posted by razec
W880 is my preference, it highly compact and unlike the nokia and moto it is not wide or long it's the best of both worlds! and another thing was that W880 has better UI than motorola, and has more menu transitions than the boring UI of nokia(no transitions at all except the nasty V-shaped and the wierd 2nd menu layout, and the media menu and modders can always mod W880 in many ways!

i just hope they put the W890 to this arena, and it will killthem all

Posted by aldrinus
@razec:

right on spot, mate! bring the W890 on

i miss the AF though

arguments aside, there really is no point in comparing these three brands or models unless we deviate from the very reason this thread was brought in: the slimness factor! and not any other feature.

peace, mates!


[ This Message was edited by: aldrinus on 2007-11-10 03:29 ]

Posted by razec

On 2007-11-10 04:26:32, aldrinus wrote:
@razec:

right on spot, mate! bring the W890 on

i miss the AF though

arguments aside, there really is no point in comparing these three brands or models unless we deviate from the very reason this thread was brought in: the slimness factor! and not any other feature.

peace, mates!


[ This Message was edited by: aldrinus on 2007-11-10 03:29 ]


I miss AF too matey anyway there are still 4 phones under 14mm and below that has AF it's the T650, K770, K550 and W610 would the author dare to put those 4 also in the arena?


Click to view updated thread with images


© Esato.com - From the Esato mobile phone discussion forum