Posted by Siosal
I vote w810 for best.
Posted by stecube
TOP: w850i
FLOP: p990i
Posted by goldenface
Interesting to see just as many people giving UIQ3 phones the thumbs up as they are thumbs down.
_________________
Esato - Phone of the Year 2006. Vote Here!
[ This Message was edited by: goldenface on 2007-01-09 15:14 ]
Posted by mikespal
Best:w850i
It's the only SE phone i have owned.
Posted by Sammy_boy
Best - Probably the K800i, still after one of these!
Worst - The W700i - Just a cheaper carbon copy of the W800i, not seen many of these about as a concequence, obviously not a success!
Posted by goldenface
@Sammy_Boy
I agree about the W700i. They would have been better just relaunching the W800i in different coloured housings.
Posted by alrodlop35
BEST: K800/K790
Perfect all around performer.
WORST: W700
Hideous colored copy of the beautifully accomplished W800i. What were they thinking?
Posted by Mukul
Best:p990i
Worst:w700i
Posted by bico
I'm not sure if it's the best phone, but it's definitely among the best: The SE W810i!
Posted by Sammy_boy
The W810i would be my second choice for best phone of 2006, excellent all-round phone, the only thing that's really marked it down for me is the lack of a lens cover which has lead to some wear on the coating of the camera on my W810i.
Posted by antichrist
best:
a) performance:p990
b) price/performance:m600
worst:
k800- it actually makes photos worse than k750i. 50% of my pictures were blurry, imo
also, i think it's necessary to mention the best/worst phone in "copy of k750i" section
best:
w810 - a walkman paint on the case and no joystick
worst:
w700 - a w800 with a 256mb card instead of 512mb
[ This Message was edited by: antichrist on 2007-01-09 20:55 ]
Posted by goldenface
@Antichrist
I've counted your first two votes and other comments noted.
Posted by happycheesecake
Best: K800i - My (Bluetooth) MP3 player, camera and... oh yeah a phone!
Worst: Z710i - Okay, who would make a phone with a 2mp camera, A2DP BT audio and then forget a camera flash?!
BTW, I think you phone geeks are being a bit hard on the W300 / Z530 phones. They're aimed at a level of the market you folks don't understand - not everyone wants multi-megapixel cameras / huge 256k colour screens on a phone. I've got a Z530i - and from a full charge its standby life is 12 days!
Posted by goldenface
@Happycheesecake
I agree somewhat. The W300 is good for the price but the keypad is very 'quirky' shall we say.
Posted by masseur
my vote is most definitly the M600, probably the best and most used SE I have ever had
and worst... P990... couldn't wait to get rid of that almost from the day I bought it!
_________________
Unless I'm very much mistaken...
reviews: i-mate V800 K700
[ This Message was edited by: masseur on 2007-01-10 10:41 ]
Posted by antichrist
@goldenface
i hope you counted my best vote the m600, not the p990, because the price/performance ratio is more important than the performance(aka specifications) itself.
Posted by Ibinco
Worst: P990i! By far the worst user expirience ever had with a SE. I felt like i was browsing through a puked out omelette. Nothing made sense..it was buggy and overpriced.
Best: K800i!!!!! After i sold my p990i(5 days after buying it) got me a k800i, takes very nice pics and does a good job as an mp3 player. Ok so it didnt have the smartphone features but it does the rest well. For smart apps i bought me an Ipaq!
Posted by goldenface
@antichrist
Your vote has been changed. Thanks.
Posted by EMS06
Looks like it's three way battle,ie, p990i, w810i and k800i.
Posted by vergon
best : w810
worst : p990
Posted by dazbradbury
Best: m600i
So good I didn't need to swap and change for any dissapointing models.
Posted by T_grr
Best: k800i, nice camera and display.
Worst: z530i, don't like the design at all.
Posted by firetech
How many of you that are voting down the P990 have actually tried it? I've noticed people saying 'it sucks' after only reading others' opinions... Inother contexts than this forum (at least), the situation seems to be like those who have it loves it, while those who've never tried it hates it...
I know some of you has owned a P990, I'm just curious.
_________________
P990i + 1GB MS + CAR-100 (+ Z600 to charge and start the CAR with)
I
my P990i[ This Message was edited by: firetech on 2007-01-10 22:55 ]
Posted by Nanu
Best:P990i all the way,
(w950i close 2nd)
i haven't used any se i dont like so couldn't come up with a "worst"
Hang on!
Worst: Any Nokia!!!
Posted by goldenface
Any more votes anyone?
looks like we have a first past the post winner. although I think I will leave it open a bit longer to see if we can build up a better picture.
Posted by apolloa
@Firetech,
I have a P990I and absolutely love it. It's great and the best phone I've owned so far.
Posted by >500
K800i
p990i
W810i
W850i
these phones above i owned are the best from
last year imo....Didnt experience much software touble with them, have little or no complaints from them....
Posted by Residentevil
Any winners, loosers yet?
Posted by chadiwrx
Best K800i
Worst J100i
Posted by roogenial
Best K800/K790
Worst J100
Posted by whistla
Best w810i
Worst w700i!!!!
Posted by PabloMDiez
Best phones:
K800/790 (Excelent camera and screen)
W810i (Excelent desing, just a little bit ugly camera design)
Worst:
W300 (Hyper ugly keypad, and white color stinks)
J100 (Not like SE Phones)
Nothing more!
Greets
Pa'D
Posted by Evil Eye
Best- P990i/M600i
Worst- J100/K310
Posted by Chrispy
umm.. best, w810, last good walkman. The k800/790 is a close second. worst, i can't really think of one
It looks from the tally at the first post, that the p990i could win best and worst categories
Posted by goldenface
@dumbrella
Well that wouldn't surprise me at all. The P990i - you either loved it or hated it - a bit like Marmite
Posted by Indiandawg
BEST - P990i anyday...
Posted by >500
can add w950i to the best list also from me. Just got one on saturday... Love it...
Posted by EMS06
@goldenface- results please, even if they may be preliminary.
Posted by goldenface
One moment!
Do you think we have a first past the post winner?
Posted by EMS06
I think the p990i, followed at the k800i then the w810i
On the worst it's tricky.
Posted by goldenface
Resutls so far after 101 votes cast: -
Best - K800i/K790a
Perfectly understandable!
Worst- P990i
This surprises me somewhat as I would have thought the P990i to be a good device - just a bit 'tricky' to manage.
Posted by masseur
no surprises there really!
Posted by borg_
Best One K800i
Posted by EMS06
I thought a lot of votes did go to the p990i. I did see the k800i at the top though. It was always going to be the any of the three: p990i, k800i or the w810i.
Posted by goldenface
I would have like a few more posts to get a better picture. Some high-end phones like the W950i hardly any votes.
_________________
Esato - Phone of the Year 2006. Vote Here!
[ This Message was edited by: goldenface on 2007-01-15 16:27 ]
Posted by Aware
I guess we can't vote for japanese
handsets, so.....
Best: P990 - Only real attempt at a convergence device.....
Worst: W850 - successor to W900??!?
Apart from A2DP, I think not!
Posted by Chrispy
@goldenface
best: marmite!
Posted by EMS06
@goldenface- it's not over yet. A lot of votes are still going to come through. Things may still change.
Posted by Residentevil
Do we have to vote for a phone that came out in 2006?
Posted by faseeh_sm
The best was P990i as it has most of the things i need but hoped it had a 3.2mp cam