Posted by WelshTom
Ok been working on a few designs. It would be a huge help if you could answer the few questions on each desin. Please note this are just 'mock up' design so the content on the pages is not complete or correct they are purely to show the intented design and layout.
Please answer:
1. Please give each design a mark out of 10 (with 10 being the best).
2. Please say which designs give a professional feel.
3. Please give any other comments about any aspect of the designs - if you think something needs adding, taking away, changing, etc etc - all comments welcome!
Here are the designs:
Many thanks,
Tom
Posted by axxxr
Ok here's what i think
Marks are as follows:
1. 7/10
2. 9/10
3. 5/10
4. 5/10
I think the 3rd one has a more professional look it.
_________________
WIDGX THE TRUTH REVEALED
[ This Message was edited by: axxxr on 2006-04-10 21:20 ]
Posted by scapevlocity
a cross between 2 & 3...
Posted by Xugaa
1. 8/10
2. 9/10
3. 7/10
4. 5/10
between 2 and 3...
2 being more professional.
(4. the colours are wrong for the name and it just looks a bit amateur, but despite that its better than what i could ever do lol)
nice designs and style by the way
Posted by EastCoastStar
i say 3 looks the best and most professional... i will do the 1/10 later, im getting off for now
Posted by scapevlocity
Sorry, didn' t read through the instructions.
1: 7/10
2: 8/10
3: 9/10
4: 5/10
I don't know how you'll be able to integrate it, but I'd like a cross between 2 & 3... Specifically because I liked the easy access in #2 to the About and FAQs pages, which I personally look for most often. I get a welcoming feeling with #3.
#1 is a bit overwhelming.
#4 looks like a "Seach not found" page.
_________________
4SALE:ALL BRAND NEW: iPod video 30gb.Canon DC-20 DVD handycam.Sony PSP value pack w/256Mb MS.would trade 4 n70/w900
[ This Message was edited by: scapevlocity on 2006-04-10 22:08 ]
Posted by WelshTom
@scapevlocity: do you think this is better?
Posted by WelshTom
Come on people over 60 of you have viewed the designs and only 4 have left comments
(if you think the designs are shit just say 
)[ This Message was edited by: WelshTom on 2006-04-10 23:43 ]
Posted by scapevlocity
whoops, i didn't see that the panel was already there on #3! sorry!
now it's kind of a tie between the old #3 and the revised #3... something doesn't seem right with the revised one, though, so i think i'll stick with #3. hehe, sorry bout that.
Posted by fatreg
number 4 for me.
seems im the odd one out though!
fatreg
Posted by Vein
Numero trois!